Scratch Fairchild 660 Worth it?

[abbey road d enfer]

The Poorchild 660 by Analag and Silent Art is one of the best, if not the best, DIY mu-comp project of all time imo.

There is no doubt that these are respectable projects. I also believe that a solid-state side-chain is perfectly capable of delivering the same performance as that in a true Fairchild.
What I contest is when someone says that a side-chain based on a dual triode with no significant iron is capable of delivering the same perfomance.
Or that the same performance as a quartet of 6386's can be achieved with a single dual vari-mu tube.

 

[CJ]

I asked Rein if he would go solid state if building the 670 today and he said yes.

 

[abbey road d enfer]

I asked Rein if he would go solid state if building the 670 today and he said yes.

Would he still have used vari-mu tubes with associated iron, when objectively better gain control elements are available? Then he may not have needed the power amp in the side-chain...

 

[xazrules]

Build one with 8x 6ba6, if i have to do one again i’m going with a ss sidechain.
But is a very educational project, after that you can build anything and know how a good sounding circuit sounds

 

[StarTrucker]

But is a very educational project, after that you can build anything

Yes something to be said for the mojo-factor and the challenge of building the real thing to original specs. Authenticity counts in addition to the final sound on this one me thinks.

Anyone have a schemo for the SS sidechain and psu? Or one from another project that would work?

 

[xazrules]

Yes something to be said for the mojo-factor and the challenge of building the real thing to original specs. Authenticity counts in addition to the final sound on this one me thinks.

Anyone have a schemo for the SS sidechain and psu? Or one from another project that would work?

I’m interested in a ss schematic too, i’ve always been interested in replacing the 6v6s and the output transformer with high power mosfets.
I think it’s impossible to build one with exact same specs or mojo, the most interesting part for me is to understand how a topology sounds, and with comp you know you are on the mount everest